Fact-Checking Nigel Farage: Produce Close Countries Ban Migrant Children From Pose Down Schools?

Steve Peers

I was planning to aspect until afterward Easter to comment inwards exceptional on the European Union police issues inwards the UK’s full general election. But yesterday’s reported comments past times Nigel Farage, the leader of the UK of Britain in addition to Northern Republic of Ireland Independence Party, need an immediate brusque reply. In his view, the children of migrants should non own got access to province schools or wellness for a number of years afterward their parents’ entry. He stated that this was the norm for most countries, in addition to inwards exceptional that his children could non attend province schools if he was inwards the USA on the footing of a move permit.  

Is this truthful though? In fact, the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child in addition to the Covenant on Economic, Social in addition to Cultural Rights say that main teaching should live gratuitous to all without discrimination. Perhaps it’s UKIP policy for the UK of Britain in addition to Northern Republic of Ireland to denounce these treaties; but if so, nosotros certainly should live told. In practice, the numerous studies on migrant children’s sometimes hard educational functioning certainly don’t advise that they are exclusively allowed to attend individual schools inwards most countries. For the USA inwards particular, a few seconds’ searching volition present that non exclusively are immigrant children allowed to attend province school, this fifty-fifty extends to the children of undocumented migrants.  How else could the USA own got larn a melting-pot for millions of immigrants over many decades, if their children were express to help individual schools?

It’s instructive to examine the interplay betwixt Farage’s comments in addition to the latest version of UKIP’s immigration policy. By itself, that policy is coherent, in addition to contains roughly really skillful elements – notably the exclusion of counting migrant students, in addition to the absence of whatever numerical quota or target for overall migration. Rather, the policy would acknowledge inwards exclusively skilled workers who arrive at a sure number of ‘points’ inwards the system; nurses would live exempt from the points requirement. This is like to the organization inwards several other wealthy countries.

Yet those other countries commonly let inwards menage unit of measurement members directly away, whereas Farage states explicitly that at that spot would live a lengthy delay earlier admitting dependents. In contrast, the EU’s Blue Card rules, which aim to attract highly-skilled migrants, waive whatever waiting menses for menage unit of measurement members, because such a forced separate upward of families apparently deters migrants from moving. The European Union rules merely re-create the standards inwards other wealthy countries on this point.

How many nurses – or skilled migrant workers – would motion to the UK of Britain in addition to Northern Republic of Ireland if it meant years of forced separation from their family? How many nurses could afford individual schoolhouse fees for their children, when they were hold out allowed menage unit of measurement reunion nether Farage’s plans? His statements are non merely inaccurate, but homecoming his party’s immigration policy incoherent.

On a personal note, Farage’s assertions rang faux forthwith for me, because I was a kid inwards roughly other dry ground (Canada), in addition to at that spot was no difficulty gaining admission to province school, where I had classmates who had exactly moved from the (then) Yugoslavia. How else could Canada accept a huge number of migrants every year, amongst a historically small-scale individual teaching system? Farage, on the other hand, attended individual school. Undoubtedly roughly migrants (who tin afford to do) post their children to individual schools, for linguistic or cultural reasons, because developing countries cannot afford to offering high-quality province schooling, to ensure that their children larn the correct certificate for academy entry dorsum home, or due to unproblematic personal preference for individual education.

So in all likelihood Farage met roughly unusual students every bit a individual schoolboy. But he has overgeneralised his ain sense into a universal norm, without fifty-fifty checking basic facts. UKIP styles itself every bit ‘the People’s Party’; but Farage has exactly reminded us that he is virtually every bit working-class every bit Marie Antoinette.

Share this post