For Your Data Whitney V. Robertson Example Brief

Whitney v. Robertson case brief summary
124 U.S. 190 (1888)

CASE SYNOPSIS

Plaintiff merchants filed a electrical load against accused collector of the port afterward he exacted duties on the merchants' goods in addition to the Secretary of the Treasury denied their appeal of the duties. The Circuit Court of the U.S. for the Southern District of New York entered judgment inwards favor of the collector of the port in addition to the merchants appealed.

CASE FACTS
Merchants, who imported sugars from San Domingo into the United States, alleged that they should non bring had to pay duties on their imported products because the sugars were similar to goods imported from the Hawaiian Islands, which were exempt from duties.

DISCUSSION

• The courtroom held that the treaty betwixt the U.S. in addition to the Dominican Republic did non render for whatever concessions of exceptional privileges, which exempted the imported saccharide from duties, in addition to the Court affirmed the circuit court's judgment inwards favor of the collector of the port. 
• The courtroom held that the treaty did non comprehend concessions similar those made to the Hawaiian Islands for a valuable consideration. 
• The treaty imposed an obligation upon both countries to avoid hostile legislation that would discriminate against 1 country's goods inwards favor of goods of similar graphic symbol imported from whatever other country. 
• However, the treaties were non intended to interfere amongst exceptional arrangements amongst other countries founded upon a concession of exceptional privileges.

CONCLUSION
The courtroom affirmed the judgment inwards favor of the collector of the port who exacted duties on the merchants' goods.


***
Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials.

Share this post