For Your Data Board Of Trustees V. Garrett Representative Brief

Board of Trustees v. Garrett illustration brief summary
531 U.S. 356 (2001)

CASE SYNOPSIS

Appellant's petition for writ of certiorari to the USA Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit was granted inwards a illustration involving whether respondent soil employees could convey recovered coin damages for petitioner soil agency's failure to comply amongst Title I of the Americans amongst Disabilities Act, 42 U.S.C.S. §§ 12111-12117.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The lower courtroom had held that the Americans amongst Disabilities Act (ADA) validly abrogated the States' immunity nether the Eleventh Amendment, U.S. Constitutional Amendment XI.

DISCUSSION

Relying on its prior equal protection precedent, the courtroom concluded that states were non required yesteryear U.S. Constitutional Amendment XIV to brand particular accommodations for the disabled, too thus long equally their actions towards such individuals had a rational basis.
Thus, if particular accommodations for the disabled were to hold upwards required, they would convey had to come upwards from positive constabulary too non through the Equal Protection Clause, U.S. Constitutional Amendment XIV.
Congress had non identified a history too designing of unconstitutional work discrimination yesteryear the states against the disabled because its full general findings too the anecdotal incidents inwards the ADA's legislative history vicious curt of suggesting a designing of unconstitutional discrimination on which U.S. Constitutional Amendment XIV, § 5, legislation was required to hold upwards based.
Even if a designing of discrimination were shown, however, the rights too remedies inwards the ADA were non congruent too proportional to the targeted violation given the ADA's sweeping requirements.

CONCLUSION
Judgment of the lower courtroom was reversed because Congress had non identified history too designing of unconstitutional work discrimination against disabled yesteryear states sufficient to abrogate States' Eleventh Amendment immunity.

Suggested constabulary schoolhouse report materials