For Your Data California V. Hodari Representative Brief

1. California v. Hodari instance brief summary

1. Hodari as well as his friends were approached past times constabulary as well as and so began running from them. Hodari ran from the constabulary as well as tossed a stone spell running. When caught he was constitute amongst $130 cash, the stone turned out to hold out scissure cocaine
1. California is maxim that but because the boys were running does non give ascension to reasonable suspicion to halt them
2. Government: they concur that the seize was unconstitutional because they didn’t possess got suspicion BUT the finding of the scissure stone was non production of the seizure because he was non seized until he was tackled
3. Hodari: i time the constabulary started to chase me I felt I was non complimentary to larn out so the scissure WAS fruit of the seizure
2. Seize: actually, bringing it inside physical command
1. His defense: the proffer that a seizure occurs when the officeholder past times agency of physical forcefulness or demo of potency has inwards to a greater extent than or less way restrained the freedom of a citizen
3. Does a seizure come about fifty-fifty though the dependent area does non yield? No
1. Seizure agency laying on of hands or application of physical forcefulness to trammel movement fifty-fifty when it is unsuccessful
4. Mendenhall: a soul has been seized solely if a reasonable soul would possess got believed he was non complimentary to larn out
1. Objective standard
5. Hodari did non comply amongst the demo of potency to halt so at that spot was no seizure until the constabulary had tackled him, so the cocaine was non fruit of the seizure
6. Arrest: if the bailiff had touched him
7. DISSENT: nether the Court’s holding, the dependent area volition non hold out “seized” until the constabulary practice physical command over him, regardless of how much fourth dimension lapses. Such a dominion volition significantly impede on citizens’ Fourth Amendment rights. An officeholder may betoken a citizen to halt as well as either rely on the citizen’s reply to justify his stop, or piece of employment the fourth dimension it takes the citizen to come upwards nether his command to come upwards up amongst a argue to justify his actions.

Support us by:
Visiting: http://www.fbdetox.com to rid yourself of that pesky social media addiction!
Checking out our lovely shop on Etsy: http://www.bohobuttons.com

Share this post