Law Referee 2018 Fifa Basis Cup: Officiating At Matchday Iii Inwards Grouping Phase Has Offered About Points For Give-And-Take (Analysis)

Group phase at World Cup is over. Overall, MD3 has kept a expert touchstone of refereeing. However, merely about interesting situations own got occurred. Let's brand a brusk analysis. 

Malang Diedhiou (SEN) was inwards accuse of the commencement game of MD3: Uruguay - Russia

In Group A Wilmar Roldán has officiated KSA - EGY, inwards which 2 crucial decisions own got been taken: at commencement a punishment for deliberate handball (supportable call), as well as then merely about other punishment that looked to survive a real soft call. In this case, VAR (Artur Dias from POR) has called the referee to monitor to rewatch the incident, yet he has non changed idea. According to my opinion, the punishment is equally good soft as well as mayhap fifty-fifty wrong. It should own got been annulled.

In Group B, Enrique Cáceres from Paraguay has faced the most hard game, at to the lowest degree inwards damage of crucial decisions. VAR intervened thrice: 2 punishment surface area incidents as well as a possible vehement comport past times Cristiano Ronalo. In my sentiment all the decisions taken after reviews are  at to the lowest degree supportable, but referee could own got done amend if he had spotted merely about incidents past times himself, particularly the commencement punishment as well as the activity past times Cristiano Ronaldo. The punishment for handball is real harsh, but non totally wrong. In this case, my sentiment is that referee wanted to rewatch the incident as well as asked VAR, because non sure. 

In Group C nothing extra-ordinary to survive reported, amongst 2 calm games. Ricci inwards DEN - FRA rejectd several punishment appeals, all decisions tin flame survive backed.

Nigeria - Argentine Republic was a crucial game for qualification in Group D, hither referee Cüneyt Çakır whistled a supportable punishment to Nigeria (backed past times VAR) as well as and then checked merely about other incident for a possible deliberate handball. He confirmed the determination to play on as well as explained his alternative inwards a real clear means to all players from Nigeria who were makig complaints. Also inwards that case, everything is at to the lowest degree supportable. 

In Group E Clément Turpin was corrected past times VAR, after having assigned a punishment to Costa Rica: an offside set earlier the incident annulled the call. Very expert function past times the officials inwards command room. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 few later, merely about other punishment was assigned to Costa Rica: supportable telephone band past times the French.

In both games of Group F there own got been real of import VAR involvements: the finish scored past times Republic of Korea inwards the final minutes of 2nd one-half has been confirmed past times VAR, after an offside reported past times AR2. In this occasion, nosotros had the perfect province of affairs inwards which VAR looks to survive the solely as well as the best solution: the actor who scored was inwards offside position, but the ball came from a deliberate play of an opponent, thence this was correctly assessed. In the other game, Pitana has checked a possible punishment for deliberate handball, deciding to play on (grey area, at to the lowest degree supportable), as well as he has whistled a punishment to Sweden (another supportable decision). Both these decisions were inwards my sentiment totally at referee's discretion.

In Group G everything was already decided. There were merely about interesting situations inwards Shukralla's game, including a foul whistled earlier a finish scored past times Panama. In this case, VAR was non allowed to intervene because referee had whistled earlier the goal.

Milorad Mažić has officiated Senegal - Republic of Colombia inwards Group H, this game has been crucial for qualification, as well as real probable hither nosotros had the most controversial province of affairs of MD3: a penalty, originally assigned past times referee, was as well as then annulled, after VAR review. According to the sentiment of the involved VAR, Danny Makkelie, actor had hitting the ball at first, thence it would own got been real harsh as well as penalizing to telephone band the penalty. This was the argue for which determination was changed. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 big give-and-take close the chance to visit the master determination of refeere equally clear as well as obvious mistake, followed. This volition survive the inquiry of our poll. You tin flame also vote for the best officiating of MD3.
Poll for the best officiating of MD3 volition halt on 02/07 at 09:00 CET.

Share this post