The Swiss Vote Against Costless Stimulate Of People Together With The Implications For The Uk's Membership Of The Eu

Steve Peers

There are 2 implications of the narrow vote inwards the Swiss plebiscite to renegotiate treaties amongst the European Union inwards fellowship to permit a quota on labour migration? First, together with most immediately, the vote volition acquit on Swiss relations amongst the EU. Secondly, the vote foreshadows primal aspects of the scrap concerning the UK’s human relationship amongst the EU, together with the possible renegotiation of European Union membership.

The Swiss implications

The details of what the Swiss voted for accept been incisively analysed inwards the Kent European Union rights spider web log post, here: http://blogs.kent.ac.uk/eu-rights-clinic/

So what are the broader implications? There is at nowadays a domestic constitutional obligation for the Swiss regime to renegotiate its complimentary motility treaty amongst the EU, hence that labour quotas are allowed. Of course, such a renegotiation is technically possible, but volition last politically difficult, since the European Union insisted upon this treaty every bit a quid pro quo every bit purpose of a broader parcel that included treaties on half dozen other issues, such every bit populace purchasing together with aviation access. The European Union can, together with in all likelihood will, insist on renegotiation of unopen to of these other treaties every bit a consequence.

The European Union should non last criticised if it demands a renegotiation of other treaties, every bit it had ever insisted upon this link, which is laid out expressly inwards all the treaties concerned. The Swiss populace was besides ever aware of it. Indeed, undoubtedly the link amongst the other treaties explains why the Swiss populace has voted for the complimentary motility understanding inwards 3 previous referenda (once to approve it initially, together with twice to extend it to novel Member States). And it is clear that the supporters of a ‘no’ vote inwards the novel plebiscite made the link clear to the voting public. We must conclude that the narrow bulk who voted ‘yes’ idea that this would last a cost worth paying.

After all, whatever understanding contains an chemical ingredient of quid pro quo. For instance, employees powerfulness similar to last paid fifty-fifty if they don’t work, spell employers powerfulness prefer it if employees worked without pay. Obviously both sides compromise; together with a ‘pick-and-choose’ approach volition accept consequences. If employees have down working for 3 days a calendar week instead of 5, they won’t even hence have full-time pay.

The implications for the U.K.

When re-negotiating amongst Switzerland, at to the lowest degree unopen to Member U.S.A. volition last thinking close the UK. While it used to last the illustration that the cost of the UK’s internet contribution to the European Union was the original crusade for Eurosceptics, that has been joined have down yesteryear doubts close the EU’s democratic legitimacy together with mo yesteryear concerns close large-scale immigration from novel Member States. Could the U.K. grip a plebiscite similar Switzerland’s?

Legally speaking, no. The U.K. does non accept a specific complimentary motility understanding amongst the European Union (linked to other treaties) similar Switzerland does. Rather, complimentary motility is purpose together with parcel of our membership of the EU. If nosotros desire to last rid of it, nosotros either accept to renegotiate our entire membership or exit the EU. As a affair of domestic law, nosotros could grip a plebiscite or otherwise modify the complimentary motility rules, together with breach European Union police describe spell remaining a Member. But that course of written report would last dishonest together with disreputable. If the bulk of the British people don’t similar a primal facial expression of our organization amongst the EU, nosotros should either exit or essay to modify that arrangement, spell beingness aware of the consequences of doing so.

So nosotros could enquire to renegotiate our membership every bit far every bit complimentary motility of people is concerned (among other things, of course). This is legally possible, but politically fifty-fifty to a greater extent than hard than the Swiss case. Indeed, every bit I suggested already, the negotiations amongst Switzerland could serve every bit a proxy for the possible futurity negotiation amongst the U.K. – much every bit whatever European Union negotiations concerning an independent Scotland would last a proxy for many Member States’ concerns close their separatist movements. Castilian politicians await at Edinburgh, together with mean value of Barcelona.

It seems likely, then, that nosotros are close to witness a ‘dry run’ for a possible British renegotiation process. This volition furnish a useful laboratory to evidence the theory that renegotiating the UK’s European Union membership, or the U.K. leaving the EU, would solely accept (in Eurosceptics’ view) positive consequences for the UK.  

Barnard & Peers: Chapter 24

Share this post