The Possibility Of A Uk Plebiscite On The Eu: The Plot Thickens

Steve Peers

What to brand of the latest twist inwards the complicated tale of the UK's human relationship amongst the European Union?

Back inwards Jan 2013, the Conservative political party committed itself to a policy of renegotiating the UK's membership inwards the European Union yesteryear 2017, too and hence submitting the results of that renegotiation to an 'in/out' referendum, which would create upwards one's heed whether the U.K. stayed inwards the EU. It would exclusively hold out inwards a position to deliver on that hope if it won a bulk of seats inwards the adjacent full general election (May 2015), or at to the lowest degree came real around asset a bulk (possibly a minor number of MPs from other parties would back upwards its renegotiation too plebiscite pledge). So a plebiscite depended on the termination of the adjacent full general election.

Now, an 'in/out' referendum at kickoff glance seems to a greater extent than likely, amongst a alter inwards the policy of the Labour political party on March 11th to back upwards such a referendum. However, the Labour political party supports a plebiscite on a dissimilar footing than the Conservative party. It does non recollect to aim for a renegotiation of U.K. membership, but rather supports an 'in/out' referendum only if there is an amendment to the European Union treaties which transfers important powers from the U.K. to the EU. This appears to align the Labour political party policy on this number amongst the longer-standing policy of the Liberal Democratic political party - which could hold out relevant if the ii parties create upwards one's heed to consider a coalition regime or other cast of political understanding next the 2015 election.

In fact, the European Union Act 2011 already requires a plebiscite inwards such circumstances - but it postulate exclusively hold out a plebiscite on whether to approve the changes resulting from this Treaty amendment, rather than an 'in/out' referendum.  So the alter inwards the Labour party's policy is actually exclusively meaningful if in that place is such a major Treaty amendment.

What are the odds of this? While in that place is some prospect of a major Treaty amendment to address the issues facing the eurozone, which mightiness too employ to non-eurozone United States of America that wished to participate inwards those changes, it would hold out slowly to draft a treaty which made major changes, but exempted the U.K. from them. This would hold out peculiarly slowly if those changes exclusively applied to Member United States of America applying the unmarried currency, perhaps including those Member United States of America obliged to employ it (all other Member United States of America except the U.K. too Denmark) or all non-eurozone Member United States of America that wished to participate.

This scenario could hold out combined amongst a renegotiation of the UK's position (if the Conservative political party holds a majority), or could exactly leave of absence the UK's position untouched. It would seem strange to travel yesteryear upwards the opportunity to, at the real least, clarify the human relationship betwixt the eurozone and non-eurozone Member States, which would hold out straight relevant to such a Treaty amendment.

Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 to a greater extent than probable scenario is that, if whatever amendments to the European Union main police line are deemed necessary, they volition guide keep the cast of a treaty amid a grouping of Member States, avoiding the Treaty amendment physical care for altogether. This physical care for was approved yesteryear the CJEU inwards the Pringle judgment, at to the lowest degree every bit regards the treaty establishing the European Stabilisation Mechanism. It was too applied every bit regards the financial stability treaty, afterward David Cameron vetoed the possibility of a Treaty amendment to that end. Such treaties produce non postulate all the Member States, or all their signatories, to travel into into force, too at to the lowest degree inwards some circumstances tin laissez passer on the axe work the European Union institutions to implement them.

So the internet termination of today's policy alter is a slightly increased likelihood of using such a physical care for inwards club to avoid a Treaty amendment. This was already probable inwards the trial of a Conservative government; right away it is too probable if the Labour political party takes office. This trial does zero to amend the transparency or complexity of European Union law. It would guide keep been preferable to guide keep the chance inwards the nearly futurity to consider the role too functions of the European Union to a greater extent than fundamentally, non exclusively every bit regards the UK, inwards club to endeavor to rebuild its rather tarnished democratic legitimacy. 

Barnard & Peers: chapter 2

Share this post