Rebuilding Hadrian's Wall? The Resultant Of Scottish Independence On British Edge Control

Steve Peers

It is widely believed that the Romans built Hadrian's Wall to continue marauding Picts (modern twenty-four hr menses Scots) at bay from civilised Britannia. Certainly the Wall inwards Game of Thrones is intended to continue out the angry, hairy mutants to the North.

The British Home Secretary, Theresa May, of late revived thoughts of these walls when she suggested that inwards the upshot of an independent Scotland, border command would bring to live reestablished between Scotland in addition to the residuum of the UK. At kickoff sight, this is an extreme in addition to thence unconvincing threat, reminding me of the variety of threats I sometimes number to my children inwards desperation.

 

But is this threat genuinely plausible? In particular, is at that topographic point whatever footing to her claim that the residuum of the U.K. would postulate to erect edge controls to protect itself from a highly liberal Scottish immigration policy? This fourth dimension around, the edge would non live at that topographic point to halt the Picts or the resident mutants, but rather the citizens of other countries using Scotland equally a variety of truthful cat flap to make entry to the residuum of the UK.

The starting indicate when assessing this declaration is to examine the 2 electrical flow regimes of multinational edge command inwards Europe: the Schengen organization in addition to the Common Travel Area betwixt the U.K. in addition to Ireland. The Schengen organization inwards regulation bans all internal edge checks unless at that topographic point are particular circumstances, in addition to establishes mutual rules on visas in addition to external edge controls. It does non found mutual rules on longer term immigration or asylum, although the European Union is moving to concord such rules gradually. However, third-country nationals amongst residence permits or long-stay visas bring the liberty to move inside the Schengen expanse for long periods.

In the Common Travel Area, at that topographic point are inwards regulation no internal edge checks, although Republic of Ireland inwards fact applies checks equally regards about forms of move in addition to travellers may postulate photograph ID to essay out their identity in addition to nationality. The 2 countries don't bring identical visa lists, in addition to those amongst residence permits in addition to visas from 1 province don't bring the correct to view the other one. There is too informal cooperation on immigration policy, equally examined inwards item yesteryear Bernard Ryan.

This organization has survived for close 100 years, amongst several suspensions in addition to modifications during that period. Indeed, it has survived through the final few decades of increased international travel, non to yell the Troubles. It is hard to imagine that a version of this government could non live agreed betwixt the U.K. in addition to Scotland. Moreover, introducing edge command equally regards Scotland is a to a greater extent than hard in addition to expensive proffer equally compared to Ireland, given that far to a greater extent than of the travellers concerned are crossing terra firma borders.

So it may live concluded that the Home Secretary's threat is unlikely to live carried out. Moreover, her threat breaks a telephone commutation dominion of parenting: solely threaten if necessary. Having been told off inwards plow yesteryear a Canadian telephone commutation banker in addition to a Portuguese onetime Maoist, the Scots hardly await naughty plenty to vote for independence at the moment. Of course, given her emphasis on immigration control, it is clear that the Home Secretary's existent objective is non to decease the Queen inwards the North, but rather to bolster her claim to the throne of the Conservative party, if it becomes vacant.

Barnard & Peers: chapter 2

Share this post