The Uk Government’S Position Newspaper On Northern Ireland Subsequently Brexit – Unopen To Initial Thoughts

Professor Dagmar Schiek, Queen’s University Belfast

On xvi August the U.K. government’s Department for Exiting the European Union (DEXEU) posted its long awaited position newspaper on the seat of Northern Republic of Ireland as well as Republic of Ireland after Brexit. The regime itself states that the newspaper needs to hold upwardly considered inward combination with the “Future Partnership Paper” on Custom’s arrangements, piece no cite is made of European Union citizens’ rights, which – amongst the province of affairs of Northern Republic of Ireland as well as Republic of Ireland as well as the UK’s fiscal obligations - likewise are a priority nether the EU’s strategy to negotiate the withdrawal agreement. For a outset appreciation of this seat newspaper it is worthwhile highlighting what they exercise non address.

Its outset role addresses the Belfast Peace Agreement, concluded on Good Fri 1998, with iii rattling specific negotiation proposals: European Union back upwardly for the peace procedure should hold upwardly maintained, citizenship rights position out inward the Belfast understanding should hold upwardly maintained, as well as European Union fiscal assistance for the Peace procedure should hold upwardly maintained. Two of these issues are at best loosely related to the UK’s withdrawal from the EU. The European Union is engaged inward numerous peace processes beyond its borders, as well as at that topographic point is no argue why it should halt engaging inward the Northern Irish Gaelic peace process. The inquiry whether Republic of Ireland grants citizenship to persons born inward Northern Republic of Ireland is non fifty-fifty inside the European Union competences: the Treaty on European Union does non decide who Member U.S.A. may recognise every bit citizens. These proposals exercise non cite the European Union citizenship dimension at all, every bit they rest purely on the national level. One wonders why the continuation of European Union funding for the peace procedure inward Northern Republic of Ireland is non included inward the negotiations on the UK’s fiscal liabilities: if the U.K. does non wishing to proceed paying inward the European Union budget, a partitioning of responsibilities on the funding for this budget would appear to a greater extent than logical –if only to avoid the impression that the neb may hold upwardly addressed to the European Union alone.

What is missing here? Interestingly, the negotiation seat only mentions the Belfast Agreement. This was only the outset stride inward a longer procedure overcoming conflict inward Northern Ireland, aiming at an all-Ireland economic scheme as well as guild (North South Dimension) every bit good every bit integration across the British Islands (East West Dimension). The success of such a procedure requires socio-economic as well as civic integration, amongst political institutional cooperation. Among the agreements complementing the Belfast understanding the Stormont House Agreement adds or then of those aspects, for representative past times stressing the take away to overcome discrimination on grounds of ethno-religious allegiances inward the provision of goods as well as services, housing as well as other areas.

However, the socio-economic as well as civil guild dimension of integration mainly rests on the mutual European Union membership of Republic of Ireland as well as the UK, which enabled socio-economic as well as civic transaction without frictions on the isle of Republic of Ireland every bit good every bit with Britain. European Union law, straight applicable inward both states, as well as enforced past times national courts as well as the ECJ, guarantees amid others costless merchandise inward goods as well as services, the liberty of business concern to found as well as the costless movement of workers every bit good every bit European Union citizenship rights for non-economically active persons. European Union legislation ensures regulatory harmonisation necessary for the shine functioning of this. Both accept been key to achieving a grade of normalisation accompanying the peace process, 1 facial expression of which is that citizens from other European Union Member U.S.A. accept made the isle of Republic of Ireland their home, every bit good every bit coming hither to live, function or report for limited periods. The economic scheme relies on European Union workers from beyond the U.K. or Ireland, every bit good every bit on service provision from other parts of the EU. Does the seat newspaper address these conundrums?

Its bit role (paragraphs 18-33) is focused on the Common Travel Area (CTA), correctly stating that this is a shape of cooperation for the exercise goodness of U.K. as well as Irish Gaelic citizens, allowing them the right to enter, reside, function as well as report inward each other’s’ state, piece likewise accessing or then social welfare entitlements as well as wellness services. The CTA likewise includes specific measures for securing its external borders, as well as it lacks whatsoever 1 document setting out all the principles as well as details, including enforcement mechanisms. The U.K. negotiation seat focuses on the preservation of rights to displace past times Irish Gaelic as well as U.K. citizens. However, the U.K. regime states that border as well as immigration controls for EEA nationals tin only hold upwardly addressed every bit role of the hereafter human relationship with the EU, piece stressing that immigration controls are non restricted to border controls, but tin likewise hold upwardly operated every bit controls of access to labour marketplace as well as social safety at other points.

The tertiary role of the newspaper (paragraphs 34-57) addresses the customs border. Again, the U.K. regime proposes to omit implementing border posts, as well as to demeanour all necessary controls of customs, compliance with agricultural output codes (sanitary as well as phytosanitary measures) through other controls. It assumes its divide proposals on customs are sufficient to command the movement of goods. These proposals accept been criticised for lack of practicability elsewhere already: they either reject whatsoever practical command of what volition hold upwardly a customs border, or shift the burden of those controls onto business, who volition take away to ensure compliance with European Union standards past times robust mechanisms which exercise non come upwardly for free.

Again, what is missing inward role two as well as 3? The newspaper acknowledges that it does non behave on the service sector, as well as relegates this aspect to the deep as well as particular hereafter partnership (paragraph 35) to hold upwardly negotiated after the withdrawal understanding has been concluded. Further, both sections are pre-occupied with borders, the solid reason border betwixt the U.K. as well as Ireland, which meanders at a length of to a greater extent than than 300 miles through the isle of Ireland, every bit good every bit the body of body of water border betwixt Great Britain as well as the isle of Ireland. Given the traumatic experiences of border communities during the “troubles”, this pre-occupation is understandable. However, maintaining the grade of normality achieved inward Northern Republic of Ireland as well as on the isle of Republic of Ireland every bit a whole would require a dissimilar focus, a focus on cooperation as well as integration inward socio-economic as well as civic respects. Any commitment to plough over this notwithstanding has to hold upwardly formulated.

As regards persons, the U.K. regime has non (yet) committed to maintaining the pre-conditions for costless movement of persons (including those who are non U.K. or Irish Gaelic citizens born inward Northern Republic of Ireland or Ireland), as well as thence to the preservation of an of import chemical constituent of an all-island integration. It envisages post-border controls beingness maintained, perchance modelled on the UK’s 2016 Immigration Act, which makes employers, landlords, universities as well as schools (criminally) liable for maintaining restrictions of immigrants on participation inward socio-economic life. This replacement of controls at borders past times civic controls is meant to disrupt socio-economic integration.

As regards the borders for products, the U.K. stresses that the in conclusion shape of the customs border depends on the hereafter customs relationship. Thus, solutions for problems for Northern Republic of Ireland as well as Republic of Ireland caused past times Brexit is postponed to a afterward phase inward the negotiations, after the determination of the withdrawal agreement. An exception is made for unloose energy products, every bit maintaining the mutual unloose energy marketplace is viewed every bit pivotal. Not fifty-fifty a membership of Northern Republic of Ireland inward the EEA (which would non address the customs border) has been considered.

Clearly, this is a outset draft for the points inward the withdrawal understanding that take away to hold upwardly addressed to avoid disproportionate harm to Republic of Ireland as well as Northern Republic of Ireland inward the withdrawal process. If (as at to the lowest degree 1 political political party supporting the Westminster regime has stated inward their election programme), the costless movement of goods, services as well as persons should hold upwardly maintained on the isle of Ireland, a to a greater extent than committed seat seems necessary. Since the European Union Commission as well as the European Union 27 are dedicated to achieving a solution for the rights of European Union citizens every bit good every bit for the problems of Republic of Ireland as well as Northern Ireland, at that topographic point is promise that to a greater extent than constructive solutions are yet achieved.

Barnard & Peers: chapter 27

Photo credit: Business Insider

Share this post